by Laurie Halse Anderson
I have never been so tempted to turn to the end and find out early what happened in a book. Because Speak is all about the impact one traumatic incident at a party had on a teenager\’s entire year in high school. Not knowing the whole story, the other students hate or ostracize her. She\’s riddled with guilt to the point of feeling physically ill and fear and confusion sit on her so heavy she cannot bring herself to talk to anyone: parents, teachers, friends. The self-incriminating, melodramatic inner dialog brought to mind Catcher in the Rye, and something about it made me think of The Outsiders, as well. Of all the books I\’ve read, this is one of the most realistic (and bitterly humorous) pictures of what high school is like. Attitudes of teachers and students, cliques and popularity struggles, how pointless it all can seem. Some passages like this one just made me laugh:
Mr. Stetman won\’t give up. He is determined to prove once and for all that algebra is something we will use the rest of our lives. If he succeeds, I think they should give him the Teacher of the Century Award and a two-week vacation in Hawaii, all expenses paid.
He comes to class each day with a new Real-Life Application… Today\’s Application has something to do with buying guppies at the pet store, and calculating how many guppies you could breed if you wanted to go into the guppie business. Once the guppies turn into x\’s and y\’s, my contacts fog. Class ends in a debate between the animal-rights activists, who say it is immoral to own fish, and the red-blooded capitalists, who know lots of better ways to make money than investing in fish that eat their young. I watch the snow falling outside.
I thoroughly recommend this book. It\’s funny, sad, attention-grabbing (translation: I couldn\’t put it down) and short enough that no matter how tempting, you can make it all the way to the revelation at the end without peeking.
Rating: 4/5 Published: 1999, pp 195
Read more reviews at:
It\’s All About Books
Things Mean a Lot
Leafing Through Life
Books on the Brain
This sounds very interesting. I haven\’t read Catcher in the Rye or The Outsiders, but Atwood\’s Cat\’s Eye sounds a little along these lines. I wouldn\’t go back to high school for anything! 🙂
Sounds good and YA books are appealing to me right now.
\”Of all the books I\’ve read, this is one of the most realistic (and bitterly humorous) pictures of what high school is like.\”This got me interested! I\’ll be looking for this one.
Sounds quite interesting!!Where do you find all these books? I haven\’t heard of most of the books you read!!
Trish- I wouldn\’t want to return to high school, either!Bookgal, Nymeth- I hope you read and enjoy it. I\’m curious to hear what others think of this book. It\’s one where the ending became a bit predictable, but the journey was a great story.Lauren- I used to keep track where I found all my books, but it got tedious. I think this is one I read about online, browsing through sites.
I\’ll definitely be looking for this one! I work at a high school, and I\’m always interested in books that delve into the teenage experience.Great review!
Ravenous- I\’d be curious to hear if its description matches your personal experience and observations.